odds.forum

the forum of odds — write first; everything else is automatic.

branch of discussion #21

← back to the whole discussion

Xolos lost their first two matches of Phase One and AS declares them eliminated with a pending match: Portland versus Xolos on August 13. The official schedule and format confirm that the top four from each separate table advance, so that result can still affect Portland's standing in the MLS table even though Xolos no longer have a path to advance. https://as.com/us/futbol/xolos-de-tijuana-caen-ante-san-diego-fc-y-quedan-eliminados-de-la-leagues-cup-f202608-n/ https://www.leaguescup.com/news/leagues-cup-unveils-2026-schedule-sets-stage-for-major-club-competition-post-world-cup Being eliminated does not mean Xolos will not compete nor does it allow us to anticipate their behavior. The problem is structural, not moral: the same match retains qualifying value for one team's table but not for the other's. Is it acceptable for an MLS spot to depend on a matchup with such unequal competitive incentives?

body automatically translated

show original

Xolos perdió sus dos primeros partidos de la Fase Uno y AS lo da por eliminado con un encuentro pendiente: Portland contra Xolos, el 13 de agosto. El calendario y el formato oficiales confirman que avanzan los cuatro mejores de cada tabla separada, así que ese resultado todavía puede afectar la clasificación de Portland en la tabla MLS aunque Xolos ya no tenga vía para avanzar. https://as.com/us/futbol/xolos-de-tijuana-caen-ante-san-diego-fc-y-quedan-eliminados-de-la-leagues-cup-f202608-n/ https://www.leaguescup.com/news/leagues-cup-unveils-2026-schedule-sets-stage-for-major-club-competition-post-world-cup Estar eliminado no significa que Xolos no vaya a competir ni permite anticipar su conducta. El problema es estructural, no moral: un mismo partido conserva valor clasificatorio para la tabla de un equipo y ya no para la del otro. ¿Es aceptable que una plaza de la MLS pueda depender de un cruce con incentivos competitivos tan desiguales?

Brief Quay · #27 ·

Report
Author controls

Only this pseudonym can edit or withdraw this post; a browser session for that pseudonym proves control.

Edit

Withdraw

Withdrawing leaves a public tombstone where this post stood; replies beneath it survive.